Mangetepopo gorge tragedy TV1 tonight

1–10 of 17

  • TV1 In A Flash 1 8:30pm - 10:25pm PGR Premiere: This drama tells the true story of the six Elim College students and their teacher who tragically lost their lives in a flash flood, a traumatic experience for the college and New Zealand.
  • on demand
  • It's had a mixed reaction from some of the families, it seems.
  • Too far into risk and then survival became a gamble ?.
  • I'm finally watching this tonight and finding it really hard. The whole first half hour seems to be an artificial scene by scene attempt to demonstrate Jodi having a gung-ho incompetent and careless attitude. Was she really that bad? Is it a fair presentation? Edit: Finished. Recurring overvoices asking things like "who do you blame?" when the narrative seemed to make it pretty clear that they blamed Jodi, despite all the fluff at the end. I don't think I'd bother recommending it. I can't place it straight away but it feels like it's artificially dramatising an event which just didn't need dramatising, almost to the level of insulting. Maybe that's just me.
    This post has been edited by the author on 5 July 2018 at 21:18.
  • More thoughts: I haven't read the coroner's report on this one but it came across to me as if someone had picked it up and simply decided "let's make a movie of that". As in they just found as many details as possible and tried to crunch them into a script, surrounding it with emotional paraphrasing, and making stuff up in the middle to fill gaps and for dramatic effect. Characters weren't real people. They were shallow cliched perfect people, except for several having an individual character trait which official records probably also described. I really have trouble understanding what someone hopes to achieve in making a film that's not about much else than details of how a group of kids and their teacher died. From the beginning it's known that's going to happen, and for the whole thing you're just sitting there waiting for it to happen. Entertainment? Empathy with this involved? Conveying facts of the event to an audience? Raising awareness about flooding of gorges? Filling a topic slot after winning a contract to make several telemovies for broadcast? Whatever the reason, why is a movie like this a good way to do it? Much more objective info about the events is readily available.
    This post has been edited by the author on 6 July 2018 at 04:58.
  • its a problem when you have to try and convey so many characters, like the old "blockbuster movies" that put lots of big stars in the movies, they just end up with a bunch of shallow characters and using their names to draw crowds... it was like a docudrama,
  • It would have worked better as a documentary film, I think.
  • the problem is, there is always a certain amount of emotional manipulation being attempted with dramas, for an event like this, it can be pretty difficult to watch, especially if you dont like the way its been done.
  • Yeah. I'm not too fussed with emotional manipulation if it's done well. I found some of how it came out as cringeworthy but that might be personal taste. I guess in this case I think they just bit off too much for the whole film. It was shown as a series of stuff that happened, with stereotyped characters. It really did look like every character aspect was taken from a statement in a coroner's report, or somewhere similar. Maybe some of those aspects were even exaggerated to try and make some kind of point. A problem with that approach, if it's what it was, is that these types of accident reports would usually only mention character traits if they're considered to have contributed to an accident. It doesn't meant that if you show a character with those specific traits then it'll be anything like the real person. There wasn't any serious exploration into how or why stuff happened, beyond showing a sequence of events that anyone could read in a 5 minute summary. The film seemed to be making some clear accusations about who it thought was responsible for various things, but didn't justify it with anything except the very shallow characters. Jodi, in particular, was just shown as being a completely reckless person. Even IF the specific facts were correct, we didn't get any depth into why she might have been acting like that.
If this post breaches forum rules, please flag it for review.
1–10 of 17

Forum The campfire
Started by waynowski
On 1 July 2018
Replies 16
Permanent link
View topic
View definition file /whio/view/topic.xml.cfm overridden by /custom/view/~custom.xml.cfm
Controller /whio/view/topic/controller.cfm
Title Forums → Mangetepopo gorge tragedy TV1 tonight | The campfire | Forums
Template forums-2012
Boxes in container 1
Key On request? Generated? Title File Template Class Cache (min) Cache key From cache? Time (ms)
core_heading No Yes /whio/box/core_heading.cfm 0 - No 0
Topic No Yes /whio/view/topic/Topic.cfm 0 - No 78
administrator_controls No No /whio/view/topic/administrator_controls.cfm gradientBox 0 - -
Form Yes No /whio/view/topic/Form.cfm gradientBox 0 - -
Boxes in container 2
Key On request? Generated? Title File Template Class Cache (min) Cache key From cache? Time (ms)
dfp No Yes /custom/box/dfp.cfm null 30 - No 0
forum_search No Yes Search forums /whio/box/forum_search.cfm 0 - No 4
controls No Yes About this topic /whio/view/topic/controls.cfm 0 - No 0
  • Key: Filename of box.
  • On Request? "On request" boxes are not always used in a view.
  • Generated? "On request" boxes are only generated as needed; others are always generated (unless retrieved from the cache).
  • Title: Box title. Set in view definition but may be overridden.
  • File: The file that is used to generate the box content. This value is determined on application start by a file scan. If blank, the content is usually generated by the controller -- or the file is missing.
  • Template: which box template file to use (useful for major changes). Looks for /custom/template/box/[template].cfm first and /whio/template/box/[template].cfm second.
  • Class: what CSS class to apply to the box (useful for aesthetic tweaks).
  • Cache (min): cached item must be fresher than this.
  • Cache key: how the cache record is identified. {Placeholders} may be used.
  • From cache? Was the content of this box drawn from the cache?