Closed cell foam or air mat?

31–39 of 39

  • I thought about doing that with my mat but have never had the need. You should get better insulation with the foam pad on top but it stops counting when it slides off the inflatable
  • What's the logic for the 'foam on top'?
  • I've seen this discussed elsewhere (without much agreement :smile:) Thermally, it doesn't make any difference if the ccf mat is on top or bottom. The rate of energy loss (Er) depends on the temperature difference (deltaT) between you and the ground and the effective heat transfer rate of the system (Rs). Er = deltaT / Rs The R value is for the whole system - you can't add the individual r-values (unless both materials are solid and in good contact - which they are not in this case). In practice, there *is* a small initial difference in rate of heat loss - until the layers reach thermal equlibrium (which will happen in minutes). However, the ccf mat on the bottom is a lot more comfortable !
    This post has been edited by the author on 1 June 2018 at 20:35.
  • Suspect there's more to it than that @bernieq. My suspiscions: 1) point compression: closed cell foam drops from its nominal R to much lower numbers where it is compressed. Eg hips, side sleeping. So I'd suspect it performs better for R where weight is more evenly distributed - ie if its on the bottom with the inflatable spreading the weight. 2) 'wrap'. Presumably there's an insulation benefit from sinking into your mat rather than lying flat on top. Draughts and lateral radiation from the underside of your body would be reduced by sinking into the foam. So foam on top? 3) Conductivity at skin / mat barrier. Inflatables are well insulated vertically but not horizontally. The external layer feels as if it conducts heat quite well. So that layer in contact with your skin may well be conducting heat away laterally to reradiate back into the ether. Foam will insulate as well laterally as vertically so should be better in this regard. Which I'm guessing is why foam feels warmer to the touch, even if the overall heat loss is higher. So foam on top? Which all leaves me no clearer ad to which order is best!
    This post has been edited by the author on 2 June 2018 at 08:22.
  • Yes, the very fine detail is tricky indeed. I suspect it doesn't make an appreciable difference. I will note that I was commenting only on heat loss through conductivity, not radiation or convection. 1. Fair point but I think the amount is insignificant. Many years on only a ccf mat without noticing cold points at hip or shoulder. 2. What you might gain from wrap (radiation) needs to be offset by what you lose from compression (conductivity). 3. Skin / mat barrier? You're tougher than me! I use a down sleeping bag between me and the mat :smile:
  • > Many years on only a ccf mat without noticing cold points at hip or shoulder Interesting. Cold at compression points is _the_ reason I'd never go back to ccf. Guess it depends on sleeping position. And wussiness.
  • Do they sell electric blankets? Like the same technology they use with those heated jackets. I'm sure one quite thin and light could be made. Connect it to a small battery pack.
  • Welcome back to the days of 100l packs unless you make it solar powered
  • I actually found one made by a Korean company it's a blanket weighs 350g and stays heated for 9 hours charge by a simply battery charger.
If this post breaches forum rules, please flag it for review.
31–39 of 39

Forum Gear talk
Started by fdi4r978fg
On 28 May 2018
Replies 38
Permanent link
View topic
View definition file /whio/view/topic.xml.cfm overridden by /custom/view/~custom.xml.cfm
Controller /whio/view/topic/controller.cfm
Title Forums → Closed cell foam or air mat? | Gear talk | Forums
Template forums-2012
Boxes in container 1
Key On request? Generated? Title File Template Class Cache (min) Cache key From cache? Time (ms)
core_heading No Yes /whio/box/core_heading.cfm 0 - No 1
Topic No Yes /whio/view/topic/Topic.cfm 0 - No 62
administrator_controls No No /whio/view/topic/administrator_controls.cfm gradientBox 0 - -
Form Yes No /whio/view/topic/Form.cfm gradientBox 0 - -
Boxes in container 2
Key On request? Generated? Title File Template Class Cache (min) Cache key From cache? Time (ms)
dfp No Yes /custom/box/dfp.cfm null 30 - No 0
forum_search No Yes Search forums /whio/box/forum_search.cfm 0 - No 4
controls No Yes About this topic /whio/view/topic/controls.cfm 0 - No 0
  • Key: Filename of box.
  • On Request? "On request" boxes are not always used in a view.
  • Generated? "On request" boxes are only generated as needed; others are always generated (unless retrieved from the cache).
  • Title: Box title. Set in view definition but may be overridden.
  • File: The file that is used to generate the box content. This value is determined on application start by a file scan. If blank, the content is usually generated by the controller -- or the file is missing.
  • Template: which box template file to use (useful for major changes). Looks for /custom/template/box/[template].cfm first and /whio/template/box/[template].cfm second.
  • Class: what CSS class to apply to the box (useful for aesthetic tweaks).
  • Cache (min): cached item must be fresher than this.
  • Cache key: how the cache record is identified. {Placeholders} may be used.
  • From cache? Was the content of this box drawn from the cache?